Hitler's Jewish Soldiers Price Documentary
This documentary examines the extraordinary and deeply contradictory experiences of Germans with Jewish ancestry who served in Hitler’s armed forces during World War II. Through archival material, historical analysis by Bryan Mark Rigg, and firsthand testimony from veterans including Werner Goldberg, Hansgert Falkenberg, Arno Spitz, and Helmut Kopp, the film explores Nazi racial classifications, the Nuremberg Laws, military exemptions, concealment of Jewish ancestry, and the difficult choices these men faced between military service, persecution, and survival. It also follows soldiers who attempted to protect Jewish relatives, witnessed aspects of Nazi persecution, or survived by remaining inside the very military system that threatened their families. The documentary ultimately explores questions of identity, loyalty, survival, complicity, and the contradictions within Nazi racial policy.
Transcript.
Detected language: English. Generated once and stored with this media record. Click any timestamp to seek the video.
This is Private Werner Goldberg.
In 1939, a Berlin newspaper labeled him as the ideal German soldier.
His picture was used on a recruiting poster for the Wehrmacht, Hitler's army.
He served in the German army until 1940.
He was dismissed because of his last name, Goldberg.
Werner Goldberg, the ideal German soldier, was a Jew.
Goldberg, your name? You are Aryan?
I said, I don't know what that is.
He said, I tell you, stand up. You are not Aryan.
I said, I must ask my father.
What follows is a very strange story about men who, despite their Jewish ancestry,
were drafted into the same Nazi army that was out to destroy their Jewish relatives.
The Nazis called these men Mischling.
I didn't want to join the Wehrmacht. I had to go to the Wehrmacht.
I also put up a tent. I also put up a tent. Here, around, here.
I am also a Yeshiva soldier, and of course, what I thought to myself,
all this is what I need, that maybe my father, my mother, someone in my family will see me,
here is our son, a German soldier, with a cross on his head.
This is what I know for sure. I was proud being a soldier of part Jewish descent to become a German.
Yes. Yes, I had aspired that.
Since the Middle Ages, Jews like Moses Mendelssohn, Heinrich Heine, and Albert Einstein
have made significant contributions to German culture.
Jews were proud Germans and served with distinction in the German armies.
The rise of the Nazis in 1933 and Hitler's consolidation of power
brought deep and ultimately destructive changes to Germany.
Life began to change radically for the half million German Jews.
And their part Jewish children and relatives.
All around them, the Nazi racial policies were put into practice.
Jewish shops were boycotted. Jews were forced out of their professions.
Life became more and more dangerous for Jews in Germany.
The Nazis put the infamous 1935 Nuremberg laws into practice.
These laws changed the citizenship rights of the Jews.
But who was a Jew according to the 1935 Nuremberg laws?
A person with two Jewish parents was considered Jewish.
A full Jew and was not drafted into the army.
Full Jews in the army were summarily dismissed.
Mischling was a derogatory German term for those of mixed blood.
Mischling were drafted into the army.
A half-Jew with a Jewish mother or father was drafted.
Quarter Jews and eighth Jews were also drafted.
The Nuremberg laws dealt with two things.
One is the so-called law on human rights and German dignity.
It determined that Jews do not belong to the German nation.
The other is the Law on Citizenship.
It determined that Jews do not belong to Germany.
They are the subjects of the German state.
After determining who is not German,
now we need to determine who is Jewish.
And that's what they did.
Of course, they were drafted into the army.
American history professor Brian Mark Rigg
researched the issue and wrote a book on the subject.
The term Mischlinge was used for mutts, dogs, crossbreeds and so on.
It was a horrible term.
And really, with the Nazi takeover of power in 1933
and then with the Nuremberg laws in 1935,
was this term readily used for people?
Some of these offspring of mixed marriages
identified with the Nazi-ruled government.
They served in every branch, were of nearly every rank.
Some stayed in the army for the security it offered.
A very few were like Air Force General Erhard Milch,
who was assistant to Nazi Field Marshal Hermann Göring.
He knew about slave labor going to Auschwitz.
He knew about experiments going on in Dachau.
And he was a really nasty individual.
He was a Nazi party member and so on.
But he's a small, small minority of most of these people.
Only a very few of the part-Jewish officers were like Milch.
Major Ernst Blanc received a shocking assignment
to rescue the 6th Lubavitch Rebbe from Poland's Warsaw Ghetto.
Now, when Blanc gets up there,
and he's going up to ultra-high ground,
he sees some Hasidic Lubavitcher Jews,
and he's asking them,
Hey, where is the Rebbe?
We want to rescue him.
And the Lubavitchers are like,
Yeah, sure you do.
And we want to join the German army.
But eventually, Blanc gets them to agree to this.
They, of course, believe he's an angel in human form.
He looks over to Rebbe Schneerson,
and he says, Don't worry about it.
I'm half-Jewish.
I'm here to protect you.
You know, Meshuggah.
The next day, he escorted them to the border of Lithuania.
Then he bid them farewell.
And then Rebbe Schneerson went up to Riga,
waiting there for his visa from the United States.
Not all the part-Jewish soldiers were of high rank.
Some were simple soldiers,
who served in all aspects of the armed forces.
And within the context of the military,
I conservatively estimate that 60,000 half-Jews
and 90,000 quarter-Jews served in the German armed forces
during World War II.
And these people were in no man's land in many ways.
One way was, OK, yeah, they're not full Jews.
They're not going to be persecuted 100%.
But also, they're not Aryan,
so they're not going to be treated as 100% German citizens.
The Nazi rule brought with it many odious surprises.
Imagine what it was like for a boy
who thought he was immune from the Nazi horrors
to one day find out that, according to the Nazis,
he was in fact a Jew.
Werner Goldberg was brought up Lutheran.
He didn't discover his father was Jewish
until the headmaster, a Nazi party member,
came into his Berlin classroom
to separate the Jews from the Aryans.
I got to home and asked my father,
what is Aryan and what is not Aryan?
And so he told me,
yes, our family is a Jewish family.
I said, you are not Jewish.
No, I am a Christian.
And I got Christian in 1902.
But we never talked about this.
We talked about Jewish history.
We talked about
the
Old Testament.
That was for both the same.
But we never told about race.
What is, what race?
That was all German.
Young Werner Goldberg didn't want to join the Hitler Youth
because he'd have to wear a cap with a swastika.
I was in the Boy Scout organization.
And in there,
the Hitler Youth,
they asked me
if I
would take
the swastika.
And I said, I didn't want this.
And so they told me,
I should go out.
Not all boys were surprised to find they were Jewish.
Helmut Kopp knew his mother was Jewish.
Kopp's Jewish mother died when he was an infant.
Because of complicated family matters,
he was placed in Berlin's Ahava Jewish Orphanage.
He was circumcised when he was 12 years old.
And there, I have to say,
I was a child,
and still an orthodox home.
All the holidays were held there.
For example,
the dishes were coughed up.
Yes?
The dishes were coughed up.
When a plate of milk
was placed on top of meat,
it wasn't right.
I had, I was,
I had a bar mitzvah
in a Jewish orphanage.
I also laid twigs.
Twigs.
I also laid them.
Around here.
His mother married him in German.
She was a Jewish mother,
and he was a Christian.
And I don't know
how they lived,
but she remained Jewish.
But it wasn't something
out of the ordinary.
Of course he wasn't Jewish
in the German sense,
in Germany.
According to the halacha,
he was Jewish.
When we came to Israel
in 1934,
my father thought
that my mother's parents,
Helmut's mother's sister,
would come to Israel.
He sent them an affidavit
from the British government
and they came to Israel.
And I,
they couldn't take me
because I,
I was called Jacob.
And they had,
the Nazis had
very big differences
between the Jews and the Jews.
They didn't just take
a 14-year-old boy
and go to Palestine.
That didn't work.
They wanted him to go to Israel.
Even though he wasn't Jewish,
they organized it,
that is,
they made him an American.
He had a relationship
at the age of 14, 15,
with the Hitler Youth,
apparently,
as friends,
like in school.
There was a sense of love
that he had.
Apart from that,
I always say,
what he behaved as a child
is something else.
We have the same grandmother,
and he's this,
and he's that,
and it's like,
I don't want to say brother,
but he's that,
right?
And if I had the sense of doubt
that he could have done something,
that he was this,
I wouldn't have talked to him.
Helmut Koch
left the Jewish orphanage
and eventually
was drafted into the army.
And there,
first-grade children
were also brought in.
So,
I already have
the explanation
in the pattern
that
I am Aryan or Jewish.
And there,
I also crossed out
two parents
as Aryan.
I went in as Aryan
because I signed
the explanation
in Aryan.
Yes.
And there,
I have,
I,
before that,
I had already
thought it all out.
I,
how I was
drafted
on the 2nd,
12th,
and then,
we stood
in front
of each other
and then,
we stood
in front
of each other
again,
all naked
in front of the
investigation commission
and then,
they said,
what do you have there?
And there,
the other comrades,
with seven,
we stood in a row
and there,
they said,
yes,
the head,
it had a Jewish pimple.
And there,
I said,
no.
And there,
there were,
there were
all in uniform,
the top.
And I said,
no,
I had a phimosis
and you can still see,
I have
three
and,
how,
when was that
with the phimosis,
did you ask?
I said,
yes,
I was 12 years old.
They did it like this
and,
and then,
it was good.
And then,
a doctor came
and then,
put on
rubber gloves
and then,
he turned
my spine
back and forth
and then,
he said,
yes,
that can be
phimosis.
Why we don't see
these people being sent off
straight to the camps
was a political decision.
Hitler and the Nazis
did not want
to persecute them
too much
because they knew
they would ostracize
Aryan relatives
who were in the economy,
business,
you know,
government
and in the military.
Hansgert Falkenberg
knew that his mother
was Jewish
and had converted
to Christianity.
My mother's side
was Jewish
and there were
very,
very big
tensions
with her mother.
It was a very
strange fact
that I never,
together
with my grandmother,
went to the
Stettin Synagogue
because
my mother
had forbidden it
more or less.
Me and my grandmother
went
to the Jewish
cemetery
and I could
see the stones.
This is strange
Hebrew scripture.
Then I saw
my past
is in a way
different
from the past
of others
of my
same age.
By the
strange
biology
teacher
I still
remember
his name
Tobias
who told
Aryans
are the
leading
race
and
Mixlings
are weaklings.
I thought
I have to
prove the
contrary.
This
consciousness
I will
prove
as far
as I can
with my
physical
ability.
To tell
this is
all nonsense
what you
talk
about
superiority.
Falkenberg's
Jewish mother
fled to England
with her
husband and
daughter.
Falkenberg
decided to
stay in
Germany
because
of the
promise
of a
university
scholarship.
But
instead
he found
himself
drafted
into
the
German
army.
To
lead
in a
paragraph
Mixlings
should not
go to
the
Wehrmacht.
So every
German
Mixling
had to
go
had to
be a
soldier.
There were
units just
around
the
border
to
Poland.
So we
were
sent to
the
Wehrmacht.
Two days
later the
British
declared
war.
Germany's
full Jews
were exempt
from the
draft but
not the
half Jews.
In his
speech before
the Reichstag
in 1939
Hitler
declared he
would
exterminate
all Jews.
It was
during this
period in
about 1939
that a
German
leader
declared
war.
Hitler
was
making
the
perfect
statement
to
our
people.
He
was
convincing
his
people
that
we
have
to
do
something
that
Once a week, she had her star already, but we would meet at the end of the streetcar
station and walk in the forest.
And that was quite painful.
It was quite clear that I would not go in my uniform to the usual aid pension and take
her up, but that we wouldn't meet somewhere outside, not to be observed or so.
I just thought if we are for ourselves for a time, not seen by others or so, or not even
asked by unknown people, what does a soldier there, somebody with a yellow star, yeah.
She was much more important than the star.
In St. Louis, she was the most important woman in the world.
Instead of wearing the German uniform, did it occur to Falkenberg to slip away from the
army?
I had no connections, never, to any enemies, to any group of resistance or so.
Once I tried even very late to escape to Switzerland, and I constructed it very carefully.
And after six weeks of learning.
Really, to ski and all that, I first found out that it is very, very risky.
And second, that there's even a chance that the Swiss sent me back to Germany.
Europe was fascistic.
Even Switzerland was in some way, fascistic.
I didn't think about giving someone a chance to escape from the army.
Where would he escape?
Where would he go?
Where would he go?
Where would they take him?
Where would they take him?
Here you can escape.
There you can't.
This is a photograph of Arno Spitz, taken with his family in their backyard in Berlin.
He is wearing a paratroop uniform with three iron cross metals for bravery.
Arno Spitz was raised in a privileged environment.
His grandfather was a successful businessman.
Arno Spitz's father grew up in a comfortable upper middle class Jewish family that had
converted to Christianity.
Spitz's father cared little for religion.
And married a non-Jewish German woman.
By 1937, Spitz's father had fled Nazi Germany for the United States.
My father was not brought up in the Jewish faith at all.
But, of course, he had been, most, not all, of his friends were Jewish.
And my father left after the takeover of Hitler.
Arno Spitz was sent with his unit to the front lines in Denmark.
He was never asked if he was part German.
And it might have been that just at that time, there was some inquiries about the
ancestry of soldiers and that nobody cared about that issue.
Nobody ever came of the idea that I could have a Jewish ancestry.
I was, I did not look at it at all.
During his army service, Arno Spitz was decorated three times with the iron cross for bravery.
Arno Spitz was sent with his unit to the front lines in Denmark.
At that time was my first combat.
I was in a very extreme situation there with a paratroop battalion.
And I was shown by my captain the bunker that I was supposed to take together with 10, 12 or so other soldiers.
And on a little, very little elevation, there were the Russian bunkers built.
And while I was moving ahead on my head and my knees,
those bullets of these two centimeter guns behind me always flew above my head.
So I could not raise my head at all because it would have been shorn off immediately.
And then I rose up and took my machine pistol and wanted to break into the bunker.
But then I noticed there were two Russian soldiers lying dead on the right side of the bunker.
So I sprayed them with my guns in order to make sure whether they were dead or not.
But they were dead. I'm glad they were dead.
And I went into that bunker and the bunker was empty.
It was such a, and dramatic.
There was the village, we couldn't see any Russians right at the border of that village.
We were about 100 meters or so from the border of that village.
We went back into that village and at the beginning of a street,
this orderly put up his, set up his machine gun and shot along the road of that village.
And we had counter fire.
And after a short time, the orderly was dead.
The battalion commander decorated me right away with an iron cross.
But, well, this iron cross meant a lot to me.
Probably at that time, I might have recalled for myself that I was part Jewish.
And I said, well, Jewish people are often claimed to be cowards.
And my mother, even my mother, who was very pro-Semitic.
My mother was very pro-Semitic.
But even she told me once, Jewish people are cowards.
And I thought of that at that moment.
I said, this I recall quite well.
That said, you see, I'm not a coward.
Historians believe that as many as 20 men who served in the German army during World War II
eventually immigrated to Israel.
Some fought for the foundation of the Jewish state.
Ephraim Glaser was born Jewish in Hungary and today lives in Haifa, Israel.
During the Second World War, Glaser was captured by the Nazis and escaped.
He lived in the forest and soon found himself starving.
He approached a German army base to beg for food, claiming he was Aryan.
I came out of a Hungarian camp, a work camp, in a terrible situation,
with thorns and wounds and all kinds of troubles.
Suddenly I arrive at a place, you have to understand this from our point of view,
that suddenly I arrive at a place where they respect me.
The Germans looked at me with respect.
No, it was all an accident.
An accident, really an accident, an accident of an accident.
And I arrived to a German army.
I arrived to a German army because of anger.
And because of my arrogance, because of Aryanism,
I was able to get along quite well with the Jews as a non-Jew,
as one who looks like a non-Jew.
And that's how I managed to go around for about two weeks.
Two weeks, that's what it was, without any documents,
without any connection.
And that's how I managed to get along quite well with the Jews as a non-Jew.
Glazer reached a German supply base,
knocked on the door,
and met a very friendly German officer.
To this day, it remains a mystery to me
why and how this man went and helped us in all kinds of difficult cases.
I have a suggestion for you.
Maybe you are willing to join our unit as an interpreter
for Hungarian, for German, for everything.
Here we have the right to translate.
Glazer agreed to the offer.
The Russian border was far away,
and suddenly Glazer discovered he had dangerously incriminating evidence with him.
I had a German passport, and I began to take off my shoes.
And suddenly I discovered that I had some very, very dangerous and dangerous things
in my non-Jewish eyes.
And those were some pictures of my father with a beard and lips,
and my mother, and my family, and my brothers.
From Palestine, from Israel, they sent us pictures.
And from behind, there was a sanctuary in Hebrew.
And after that, I came and saw that I had something else.
At the time, the Hungarians asked us to give them our prayer bag.
But I, in a rage, left to myself the prayer bag
that came from the Land of Israel,
which reminds us of Jerusalem,
with the Western Wall,
and the beautiful Tafur.
And I see that I am transmitting my doubts,
and I find these things.
What am I going to do?
For some reason, I cannot explain,
I decided that I will not throw these pictures away,
I will wrap them in a blanket,
and I will put them in my bag,
of the Germans' flags,
of the German flags.
That's where I put the pictures.
And when I saw the prayer bag,
I wrapped it in a blanket,
and I put it in the German flag.
Hansgert Falkenberg's godmother was a Nazi party member.
Even so, she was shocked to hear
that Falkenberg's Jewish grandmother
had been deported to a concentration camp in Poland.
And she asked, just by the way,
what about Umchen, my grandmother?
And I said,
didn't you hear about it?
And she said, no, what?
She has been transported to Poland three weeks ago,
with all Jews still staying in Stettin,
to the east.
And she said, this is horrible.
Why didn't you tell me?
Something has to be done with it.
And I said, you are a member of the party,
you are a Nazi.
And she said, yes, yes, yes, yes,
I still believe that the Jews are unhappy for Germany,
but it has nothing to do with your grandmother.
In 1940, the Nazi government
plugged the loophole in their draft laws,
and the paradox of having Jews serving in the German army
and the half-Jews serving in the army at that time
was to be demobilized.
The half-Jews who were freed
could no longer enjoy the safety of being in the army,
and now found themselves
at the mercy of the Gestapo.
But the army was a place where soldiers were usually accepted
if they did their jobs,
and not too many questions were asked,
no matter what the Nazi regulations.
Werner Goldberg was offered the chance to stay in the army.
Yes, but you may stay if you want.
And I said, well, my father told me,
if everybody, everyone not want you, stay not.
And so I hear of my father's voice and went.
The Gestapo came to the units
to check if any Michelin were still in the ranks.
Falkenberg's commanding officer
gave him a chance to avoid discovery.
I have to make a proposal.
If I send you tonight to the front,
so you have a chance to stay longer with the army.
You know, this is one of the people nobody had asked,
so he did it out of his own.
I said, certainly, yes, thank you.
And I immediately went away the same night to Denmark.
That saved more than a year for me
as a soldier for the German army.
And all my school comrades,
who in the meantime were lieutenants
or...
Overlieutenants told Gerd,
stay with the Wehrmacht,
stay with the army.
That is the safest place in Germany.
Was Helmut Kupp frightened
he'd be discovered as a Jew when he was in the army?
Jeden Tag.
Jeden Tag hatte ich Angst gehabt.
Private Kupp declined his commanding officer's offer
to promote him to sergeant,
fearing his Jewish background would be discovered.
And later he had a company commander.
The company commander was a lieutenant.
He said, Kupp,
you have the good stuff for a war service officer.
Don't you want to sign up?
I said, no.
I couldn't.
Because at that moment,
for example,
you can go to Obergefreiter
or to Unteroffizier,
but then they look at the papers.
And then it gets tricky.
The war was at its peak.
But for men like Helmut Kupp,
who were living a lie under the noses of the Germans,
the future looked bleak.
He was a tank driver on the dangerous Russian front.
From the labor service directly to the army,
to the German Wehrmacht.
And since I had reported to the tank driver,
I also came to this troop.
And with the troop I was later
at the 2750th Panzerjägerabteilung.
And then we were deployed
in front of Scharkow.
And Scharkow was a...
So we took it three times.
We lost it three times.
And there we had heavy losses.
So over half of our unit.
At the high mountain combat school in Mittenwald
I was promoted to lieutenant.
I think I was proud.
I didn't...
Proud to even...
This much I know for sure.
I was proud being a soldier of part Jewish descent
to become a German officer.
Yes.
Yes, I had aspired that.
Well, we did not think that Hitler as a Nazi man,
being at the same time the highest commander of the army,
to us there was always a split
between traditional,
traditional German army
and political institutions.
There was a difference between army service
and Hitler service.
Did Kopp think that as a part Jew
his life was in danger?
Yes.
It was only to survive
that I wrote it down.
When I...
I thought about it.
In this respect,
either put me on the wall
or in the concentration camp.
I was at the command center
but the Jews were afraid of me.
And I spoke to many Germans.
This is what many people
do not understand in Israel as well.
That most of the Germans
were in the army at the time.
Those who did this,
it was a very small part
of the Germans.
And there are those who said
that I was once a Nazi soldier,
I changed my mind.
I believe him 100%.
Some say I was never a Nazi, right?
But if someone tells me
that he was a Nazi soldier
and changed his mind,
I believe him.
It is impossible to know
who was a Nazi.
There were those who believed
in the Nazi doctrine
and their Jewish origin
did not bother them.
And there were those who were soldiers
who served because it was
the right of the citizen
without having a positive impact
on the Nazi ideology.
This is an entirely individual case.
Helmut Schmidt was a Michelin
of the second degree
and became Chancellor of Germany
in 1970.
His grandfather was a Jew.
And Helmut Schmidt served
in the German army.
He was a member of the NUN-MEM.
And this motive never bothered him.
One of the most glaring examples
was Erhard Milch,
who was in charge of all the logistics
for the German Air Force.
Historians claim that Milch's father
was Jewish,
but that his mother lied
and claimed the man
who fathered her six children
was an Aryan.
This lie helped Milch become
one of the most powerful men
in Germany.
He also helped found Lufthansa Airlines.
Hitler later declared Milch
a full German Aryan
and provided him an official certificate
of Aryanization.
Theoretically,
the Jewish construction
is based on Giza.
In fact,
it is a political construction.
It is a social construction.
And it depends on the period
and on the body.
So they were given privileges.
Even when the biology says
that this man is Jewish,
the pragmatic needs
can prove that he is not Jewish.
And these privileges were given
by those who were at the highest levels
of the government.
By Goebbels,
and by Goering,
and by Hitler himself.
Hitler also turned
the Muslim cleric
and enthusiastic Nazi,
the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem,
Haj Amin al-Husseini,
into an Aryan.
They used him
in their anti-British approach
in Hitler's table talks.
Of course,
they asked him
how he,
with all the Gizan views,
could accept as a member of the United States
a man like Haj Amin al-Husseini,
who is Arab.
And Hitler says,
when you look at
Haj Amin al-Husseini's face,
you see that he has blue eyes.
Now, from where can an Arab
have blue eyes?
And of course,
he is the son of the Taliban.
Only about 2,000 exemptions
were issued.
Most Mishling didn't receive
Aryanization certificates
and returned to dangerous
and complicated civilian life.
In that life,
Werner Goldberg had to save
his Jewish father from the Gestapo
three times.
Two SS people took my father
on the Trage to the ambulance.
It was an SS ambulance.
I would like to visit my father.
It's impossible.
He is prisoner of the Gestapo.
On Christmas Eve,
when all the guards were at a party,
Goldberg rescued his father
from the German hospital.
And so it was all right.
Nobody, also a sister only.
And I thought,
I'll take my father away.
It's impossible.
So you will see that.
And I took him in a taxi
and brought him at home.
The annihilation of millions of Jews
during the Holocaust
was without precedent
in modern civilization.
The Nazis claimed
that the Jewish people
were the root cause
of all evil in the world
and had to be destroyed.
But the glaring question
is what did the Mischling know
about the Holocaust?
And when did they know it?
On the camp,
he didn't know
how much he knew about the camp.
At the commissary,
the shithouse parole was anyway
that the Jews came to the concentration camp
and were killed.
Everyone whispered that.
And you could only talk about that
with close comrades,
openly.
And I myself,
on the advance,
in the northern section,
over Lettland,
we heard at Dünerburg
that, as always,
machine guns were used
to shoot.
And we asked one of them,
that was on the advance,
and we asked one of them,
what's going on there?
And he said,
I don't even remember
if it was a soldier
or one of the,
how do you call it,
the secret police.
He just said,
oh, a criminal was executed there.
And that was all.
The soldiers,
we knew anyway
that there were Jewish prisoners
in Auschwitz or Buchenwald.
But it was always like that,
told among comrades,
not publicly.
And we also had,
I have to say,
we also suppressed it.
At least I suppressed it.
I thought,
well,
God bless you
if they catch you.
That was it.
Arno Spitz maintained
that he never served
in areas
with a Jewish population.
During the war,
I never was in areas
where there was
any Jewish population
as in Poland.
In this part of Russia,
I was not in white Russia,
I was south of Leningrad.
In this part of Russia
and in these swampy districts,
there were no Jews.
If I had heard
about what was going on
in concentration camps,
I would probably
have changed my mind
about Germany,
about German public,
about the line of command,
but I probably
wouldn't have done anything.
Tell me what could I have done
or otherwise you are shot.
The army couldn't
have done anything,
anything,
actually that much.
If I had been put
into a position
where I had to mistreat
miserable people,
captive people,
I wouldn't have done anything.
That's for sure.
I'm sure about that.
I wouldn't have done
anything brutal.
That I'm sure.
I still believe,
I believed and still believe
that only a very small part
of the German population
is involved,
had been involved
in those crimes.
In 1943,
the half-Jews were again
called back into the service
due to the German military's
need for manpower.
Hansgert Falkenberg
was called back
and sent to the organization
Todt.
Todt was a labor battalion
made up of prisoners,
Mischlings,
and other undesirables.
The workers were sent
to build roads,
work on the Atlantic wall project,
or build the deadly V-2 rockets.
And the V-2s were in a state
where every,
every fifth or sixth exploded
while they were put together.
And so,
that was more or less
a certain death.
And while he was working
in organization Todt,
Falkenberg received a letter
from his Jewish grandmother,
who was then
in a concentration camp.
And Falkenberg couldn't do
a thing to help her.
The last letters,
she wrote in French,
.
.
This week,
again,
10,000 by gas.
In July 42,
this was unimaginable.
You could only tell yourself,
people are becoming crazy there.
This cannot be the truth.
Falkenberg quickly realized
that his grandmother's reports
weren't so ridiculous,
and that his own life
was in serious danger.
He and some of his campmates
planned an escape.
One night,
during an air raid,
they stole German uniforms
and scaled the walls.
They found their way to Paris,
dressed as German officers.
So we lived in Paris,
as an OT officer,
in a hotel,
with all the privileges
of the German officers.
Getting soap and liquor,
and I didn't know what,
so I played,
I played tennis
under the Eiffel Tower.
I visited the opera.
I visited the Kamerad Comique.
And this is my Paris,
you know?
Dark,
coming from the Trocadero,
listening to
Mengelberg's
Eighth Symphony of Beethoven.
And then,
as a German officer,
now, perhaps,
being shot down
by a resistance man,
was a very, very strange situation.
In Paris,
Falkenberg met a girl
at the movie theater.
He discovered that she worked
for the general in charge
of Army service.
She forged papers
for Falkenberg,
releasing him
from the organization TOT.
And I told her,
more or less,
who I was,
that I had to get rid
of this uniform
as soon as possible.
He went back
to her general's office
at 12 o'clock in the evening.
She typed
all the papers I needed
to become,
to be dismissed
from the organization TOT.
And at the same time,
I went to Berlin
and got dismissed
the next morning.
In April 1943,
in celebration
of Hitler's birthday,
the Nazi leaders decided
to give him a present
and free Berlin
of all Jews.
At that time,
several thousand Jews
married to non-Jews
were still in the city.
Werner Goldberg's father
was arrested yet again
and taken to the Jewish
Community Center
on Rosenstrasse Avenue.
Families of those arrested
gathered in a park
across the street,
awaiting the fate
of their relatives.
This later was known
as the first protest
ever held against
the Nazi regime.
In the morning,
I stood there
and there came
an open car
from the SS.
And in the front,
a school comrade of mine
sat there.
And I went through
the police cordon
and took them at an arm.
Gerhard,
deschickt mir der Himmel.
Was los.
What's the matter?
My father is here.
Oh, you have luck.
I am the chief here.
I can't speak to you here.
Here is my card.
Call me in the evening.
I can't leave here.
You can leave.
Call me in the evening.
In the evening,
I called him
and he told me
on the telephone,
father comes back at home.
And the next morning,
he was here.
Brian Glaser wore
the German uniform
for five months
before he managed to escape
behind the Russian lines.
And that's how we stood,
dressed and dressed.
And he tells me,
there was a sergeant there,
and he tells us,
now I will teach you
something important.
We have to keep cleanliness,
we have to keep
silence,
and you have to bless
everyone you see,
from the German army,
you have to bless them.
And the blessing is
Heil Hitler.
You have to raise your hands
and tell us,
do it,
now I want to see you
how you are blessed.
So we made one return,
Heil Hitler,
and this is how we bless you.
Well, we went out to the street,
we really found
all kinds of people,
German standards,
around,
and until I got to him,
we had to get to
where we were,
this was the place
where we went to Lund,
and our room.
So I had to bless
Heil Hitler,
everyone I met on the way.
I was afraid of death,
but what?
I was afraid of death
even before that.
Even when I was in that situation,
the fear was already with me,
it sat strong with me.
The Allied invasion marked
the beginning of the end
of the Second World War.
The Red Army attacked
from the East.
The forces surrounded Germany.
The enemy encircled
Arno's Spitz from every side,
blocking any chance of escape.
And they approached
an American jeep,
and I jumped off the road
and tried to hide myself,
but there were no,
not touched any leaves
at the bushes.
So they stopped,
tried to follow me,
pointed a machine gun at me,
and the lieutenant asked me
to come up and give him my side gun.
He asked me to be seated behind him
in his jeep.
The jeep turned out.
I tipped on his shoulder
and said to him,
what are you going to do with me?
Well, he said,
we take you to camp,
a prison camp.
And I said to him,
I tell you,
I don't want to be a prisoner.
I love my freedom
just as much as you do.
And my father is an American,
Jewish American.
This was the first time
that my Jewish ancestry
came into play.
He told the driver stop.
He wanted to let me go.
The driver did not obey.
Arno Spitz was captured,
escaped,
and was captured again.
And this was an American captain.
And he said to me,
well, why did you want to escape?
I said, I don't want to be,
I don't want to be a prisoner.
I cannot stand being captive.
I'm completely free.
Just like my father,
who is a citizen
of the United States.
Oh, he said,
your father,
he said,
how can that come?
I said, my father is Jewish
and has left Germany.
Helmut Kopp was captured
by Soviet troops
and taken to a prisoner of war camp.
He was kept prisoner
for nearly two years,
from 1944 to 1946.
And now I thought,
I thought,
I said,
I went under,
I falsified my papers.
So I falsified my papers.
And then she got very angry.
And then she said,
that cannot be
with the German army.
July 1944,
in Russian captivity,
two years.
And then after two years
I came back with 44 kilos.
I weigh 84 today.
At that time I weighed 78.
And came back
and for the first time
a quarter of a year
nothing at all.
So because I looked
like a skeleton.
And there I lived
with friends.
And my circle of acquaintances
was a Jewish circle of acquaintances.
So mixed marriages.
But there were no,
at the beginning,
oh, and then I had
then I had
a girlfriend.
I had a girlfriend
before the war.
An Aryan.
But we were not allowed
to marry.
We were only allowed
so,
so secretly.
And then we got married.
Of the 160,000 Jews
living in Berlin in 1933,
only 1,500 Jews,
counting the Mischlings,
survived until the war's end.
Except for Werner Goldberg's father,
his Jewish family
all perished in the Holocaust.
After the war,
Goldberg tried to help
his neighbors
as they entered
a new period in Germany.
He helped rebuild
his Berlin neighborhood.
He established
a soup kitchen
with food he scrounged
from the Soviet army.
And even started
a fire department.
Later he became active
in German politics
and the struggle
for democracy
and minority rights.
He became a member
of the city council,
started his own political party,
and was willing
to do anything
to support
the Jewish people.
And was one of the leaders
in getting legislation passed,
granting reparations
for Jews and others
who'd suffered
at Nazi hands.
After the war,
Arno Spitz joined
his Jewish father
in Los Angeles
and became
a successful
building contractor.
When the Berlin Wall
went up dividing Germany
in 1961,
Spitz felt he needed
to return to Germany.
He supported
the Social Democratic Party.
Spitz opened
a publishing company
that aired
pro-democratic views.
Spitz lost most
of his Jewish relatives
in the Holocaust.
All of Helmut Kopp's
Jewish family
were murdered
by the Nazis,
except those
who had escaped to Israel.
Kopp and his wife
stayed in Berlin
where he worked
mainly as a truck driver
or a chauffeur.
After the war,
Hansgert Falkenberg
learned that he'd lost
all of his Jewish relatives,
including his grandmother.
He finished his education,
earning a PhD,
and established Input,
a foundation dedicated
to democracy.
Falkenberg was also
a well-known
German TV producer
and television personality.
Until his death in 2005,
Falkenberg was married
to his third wife,
an American Jewish academic.
They have a son
who had celebrated
a bar mitzvah.
Until his death in 2004,
Werner Goldberg
worked to advance
democracy in Germany.
Given all that he accomplished,
perhaps he really was
the ideal German soldier
after all.
About this record.
This documentary examines the extraordinary and deeply contradictory experiences of Germans with Jewish ancestry who served in Hitler’s armed forces during World War II. Through archival material, historical analysis by Bryan Mark Rigg, and firsthand testimony from veterans including Werner Goldberg, Hansgert Falkenberg, Arno Spitz, and Helmut Kopp, the film explores Nazi racial classifications, the Nuremberg Laws, military exemptions, concealment of Jewish ancestry, and the difficult choices these men faced between military service, persecution, and survival. It also follows soldiers who attempted to protect Jewish relatives, witnessed aspects of Nazi persecution, or survived by remaining inside the very military system that threatened their families. The documentary ultimately explores questions of identity, loyalty, survival, complicity, and the contradictions within Nazi racial policy.